Why Should You Care About Social Proof?

Social Proof is something we are not very consciously aware of
It snuck into our lives like our phone addictions. Slowly, insidiously, over time.
One description I read while researching compared it to “herd mentality.” None of us wants to be associated with that term. “No! Certainly not me!”
So, what is it and why should I care?
I read several definitions and frankly, the only one that was not offensive to my ego is this one –
“Social proof is a psychological phenomenon that leads people to look at what others are doing or saying to guide their own actions or beliefs — especially when they’re unsure about something. It taps into our innate desire as social beings to fit in and connect with others.”
Have you read the book Influence by psychologist Robert Cialdini published in 1984? Cialdini introduced the term in his book which details his decades-long research into the relationship between human behavior and persuasion.
Here’s an example of how it plays out. You need a plumber right now. What is the process you go through to choose one? Ask your friends and neighbors, read website reviews, Google search and the associated reviews…
In marketing, social proof persuades someone to interact with or purchase from you.
Our peers, social media, advertising, association with certain groups -influence many of our purchasing decisions directly and indirectly.
I’m a Green Bay Packer fan. I love the Green and Gold. I may never purchase anything in the Raiders colors, BUT the Matildas? Same colors. I love them and would buy their jerseys simply by association.

People tell me all the time Social Media doesn’t work.
It does. It’s very powerful. And if you aren’t paying attention to your online presence – it’s killing your brand.
Social Proof is like electricity. You can’t see it. You just turn on a switch and it works. Or not.
What are some prime examples?
1) Reviews, Testimonials, & Recommendations
Google reviews, website testimonials, LinkedIn recommendations, FB posts, and so on. Here’s a featured recommendation I posted on LI last week. You might be surprised how popular and effective these are. And it promotes the giver as well.
For service providers who share customer reviews, they enjoy a 17.4% higher conversion rate. In my humble opinion, that is significant.
For products and gifts, its between 32% & 47% higher conversion.
2) Awards and other Kudos
Just win a case or an Industry award? Are you a Super Lawyer?
You may not feel like its a big deal, but your prospects do. We want to work with the BEST.
This gets into sketchy territory. Don’t be too Braggadocios. No one like a blatant showoff.
Done tastefully, it is very effective. I love knowing my Chiropractor and favorite restaurants are Top Marin Picks year after year.
3) Case Studies
I know, no one reads those long stodgy academic ridiculous generic data heavy white papers much any more. Depends on your Industry.
But, hear me out. Think Client Success Stories with data.
A client sent me 4 horrendous photos, and a huge block of text from a conference she spoke at. She wanted to get a lot more training and speaking events.
I created a series of 5 posts for her and scheduled them out. She got on the radar of an Influencer in her field and was hired to do a series of webinars for her association for continuing ed. She is back to full time speaking and training.
Her profile views tripled, her search appearances increased 5X, and she added about 100 new people to her network. High quality connections interested in what she does.
4) Data and stats
How many companies have you served? How many hours of work do you save them? What percentage of efficiency increase do your clients enjoy? Has their retention rate increased? How much tax liability can you save them? What’s your win rate?
What does success look like for your Ideal Client?
Our ego LOVES stats. “Ooooo! Look at you! What a smart decision!” Stats grease the wheels for the emotions to step in and actually pull the trigger on an investment.
Here’s an example from the LI newsfeed – 21 apps that will save you 1,000 hours of work
I dare you not to click on that.
5) Social Media Presence
12 years ago, when I started out, without a website, I wasn’t terribly optimistic about how I was going to drive business as an introvert.
Until, I posted my first photo of me speaking on LinkedIn. That first photo yielded 10 inquires and 3 instant bookings. “If she’s good enough for such and such group, she’s good enough for ours.
And, group leaders talk to each other. “Was she a diva?” “Did she offer incredible value?” “Is she an engaging speaker?”
Insta-Credibility
In this era, You aren’t LEGIT without a Social Media Presence. And, I am hear to tell you – QUALITY matters. Leave the quantity and vanity metrics to TikTok stars.
Content Strategy, video, consistent posting – is the long game. AND is the gift that keeps on giving. You really aren’t legit without it.
Look at your competitors.
What are they doing?
It’s a noisy market.
Thought Leadership works. It continually amazes me how quickly and how effectively it works.
We want REAL. We want the BEST. We want to see that others have had success with you.
There is so much more to this conversation. At least a dozen other tactics, like user generated content (UGC), KPIs, tracking tools…
Most of those conversations are for larger organizations. My goal was to hit the highlights for solos and partnerships.
We can only wear so many hats. We only have so much bandwidth.
Until next time…
Angela